Skip to content

Paper, Excel, app or ERP?

रजिस्टर, Excel, ऐप या बड़ा सॉफ़्टवेयर: किसमें क्या है।

Four ways to keep a petrol pump's daily hisab. Each is right for someone. Here is what each does well, where it falls short, and what it costs, including the limits of our own app.

Paper register, Excel, Fuel Pump Book and ERP software compared
Paper registerExcel sheetFuel Pump BookDesktop / cloud ERP
Opening readings carried overNoPartly, by hand or depends on productYesYes
Fuel Sold and Expected Amount calculatedNoYesYesYes
Test litres removed automaticallyNoPartly, by hand or depends on productYesYes
Rate change split inside the shiftNoPartly, by hand or depends on productYesPartly, by hand or depends on product
Staff enter UPI and credit from the forecourtNoNoYesPartly, by hand or depends on product
Difference per nozzle and per operatorPartly, by hand or depends on productPartly, by hand or depends on productYesYes
Pending dues ledger with WhatsApp remindersNoNoYesPartly, by hand or depends on product
Shift report PDFNoPartly, by hand or depends on productYesYes
Works on any phone, no PCYesNoYesPartly, by hand or depends on product
Works without internetYesYesNoPartly, by hand or depends on product
GST invoices, Tally exportNoNoNoYes
Tank stock from dip readingsPartly, by hand or depends on productPartly, by hand or depends on productNoYes
Setup timeNoneAn afternoonAbout 10 minutesDays, with the vendor
CostRs.0Rs.0₹150 / nozzle / month₹500 / month to lakhs, plus AMC

means partly: possible by hand, or depends on the product. ERP features and prices vary a lot by vendor; see the software guide for ten named products.

Paper shift register

Good for
Needs nothing: no phone, no internet, no fee. Everyone knows how to fill it. Legal Metrology and the oil company are used to seeing it.
Falls short
Every reading is copied by hand, every amount is multiplied on a calculator, and tests and rate changes depend on memory. "Short somewhere" is the usual result, and finding the nozzle three days later is impossible. A wet or lost book is a lost month.

Paper vs app, step by step

Excel sheet

Good for
Free, and the formulas do the multiplication. Our free template has Fuel Sold, Expected, Collected and Difference built in, with a guard against a closing reading lower than the opening.
Falls short
Lives on one laptop, filled the next morning from slips. Staff cannot enter UPI or credit sales during the shift. Readings are still copied by hand into the next day's row, and inserting rows breaks formulas.

DSR format with the Excel formulas

Fuel Pump Book (phone app)

Good for
Readings carry over, tests come off, rate changes split, staff log entries from the forecourt, and the Difference is per nozzle and per operator every shift. Installs from the browser on any phone; about 10 minutes to set up.
Falls short
Needs mobile data to save entries. Does not do GST invoices, Tally export, dip-based tank stock or dispenser automation. One account per pump today; more than one pump is a Custom plan.

What it does and does not do

Desktop or cloud ERP

Good for
Everything in one system: shifts, billing, GST, stock from dips, Tally export, loyalty, SMS. Right for pumps whose accountant wants daily entries and for larger outlets.
Falls short
A PC at the pump (for desktop products), setup days, training, and a price that may include setup fees, AMC and per-user or per-PC charges. Staff entries from the forecourt depend on the vendor's app. More screens than a single-pump owner needs for the daily hisab.

Ten products compared, with published prices

Choosing questions

Is a paper register really worse than an app?

Not for everything. Paper needs no internet, no phone and no fee. It is worse at the arithmetic: carrying readings over, subtracting tests, splitting a rate change and finding which nozzle is short. Those are where the money leaks.

Can I just use Excel for my petrol pump?

Yes, if you close one or two dispensers yourself every day. Our DSR format guide gives the columns and formulas. Excel cannot take entries from staff on the forecourt during the shift, and copying readings by hand is where digit errors happen.

When do I need a full ERP instead of Fuel Pump Book?

When GST invoices, Tally export or dip-based tank stock are the main job, or when a PC at the pump with a local vendor is what you want. Fuel Pump Book is the shift hisab on a phone; it does not do those.

Can I use Fuel Pump Book alongside my register for a while?

Yes, that is how most owners start. Run both for the 15 free days and see whether the app's Difference matches your register. Then decide.

Run the app next to your register for 15 days.

15 दिन मुफ़्त। कोई पेमेंट नहीं चाहिए।

15 days free, no payment needed to start. Set up your dispensers and staff in about 10 minutes.